May 8, 2013; St. Louis, MO, USA; St. Louis Blues center Andy McDonald (10) takes a shot against the Los Angeles Kings during the second period in game five of the first round of the 2013 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Scottrade Center. Mandatory Credit: Scott Rovak-USA TODAY Sports

At the beginning of the season I would have thought that it might in the St. Louis Blues best interest to re-sign Andy McDonald to a one year deal at a much lower salary, but after watching him this season I no longer feel the same way.

McDonald has always struggled with injuries while in St. Louis, but when he was on the ice he produced game in and game out.  His speed and hockey sense really shined through in past seasons, but this year something has been missing.  Aside from shootout glory, McDonald hasn’t looked as fast or strong on the puck.  He seems to be fearful heading into plays which has made him even less useful in the series against the Kings.

Now, with the St. Louis Blues down 3-2 in the series, maybe it is time to sit the veteran in place of one of the Blues future stars.  If McDonald was swapped out for Vladimir Tarasenko, the Blues would be adding size and not sacrificing speed or ability.  Tarasenko’s only NHL playoff games was limited to just over 5 minutes of play which was not even enough for him to get acclimated to the play.

May 4, 2013; Los Angeles, CA, USA; Los Angeles Kings defenseman Drew Doughty (8) and St. Louis Blues left wing Andy McDonald (10) collide in game three of the first round of the 2013 Stanley Cup playoffs at Staples Center. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

The real question though whether or not the Blues force a game 7 tonight will be the value of Andy McDonald.  As an unrestricted free-agent this offseason, McDonald will almost certainly be searching for a new home.  At the NHL trade deadline this season, the Blues did not try to move McDonald having the confidence that he would be useful if the team was to reach to postseason.  Now that other teams have seen that he cannot play a major role against a physical team like the Kings, what might his future hold?

Although Andy Mac’s play hasn’t been what it once was, I don’t think it is time for him to hang up the skates.  What McDonald is going to have to do is to find a new role with a new team.  Playing on a third line or a fourth line might benefit McDonald’s numbers and help him to be a bigger asset to a team.

So Blues fans, what do you think of Andy McDonald?  Where do you think he will wind up and how much do you think he is worth?  Let us know on Facebook or in the comments below.

LET’S GO BLUES!

-Alex Hodschayan

May 6 2013; Los Angeles, CA, USA; Los Angeles Kings defenseman Robyn Regehr (44) checks St. Loius Blues right wing Vladiimir Tarsenko (91) into the boards in game four of the first round of the 2013 Stanley Cup playoffs at Staples Center. The Kings defeated the Blues 4-3 to tie the series 2-2. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports

All year, the St. Louis Blues have played with a perfect balance of physicality and finesse. In one instance, Ryan Reaves could pummel a guy into the boards, and the next line would have passing between TJ Oshie, David Perron and David Backes look as smooth and silky as a high-quality kimono.

Last night, we saw plenty of that same skill: Oshie tipping in a shot from Kevin Shattenkirk, Vladimir Sobotka’s sick drop pass to Jay Bouwmeester which led to the Backes goal, etc. Yet, for all that skill, the Blues lost. By the end of the third period, they didn’t even look like they deserved the win, getting completely dominated in every aspect of the game.

The tally in the “L” column came from a combination of two things: the Kings stepping up their own physical, hard-hitting play and the Blues sacrificing their own physicality for more goal-scoring attempts.

On paper, the Blues won in the hits department by a slim 46-42 margin, but in this case, the stats are a total red herring. the Kings often got two forwards deep on the forecheck and made key hits that stopped the Blues offense from ever getting started. Gassed by the time they got to the opposing blue line, St. Louis often had to peel off and start making substitutions for the next wave of Kings’ offense. Los Angeles forced the Blues into that defensive mindset after the Blues took a promising 2-0 lead.

Ken Hitchcock, for whatever reason, also broke up his CPR line (Adam Cracknell, Chris Porter and Reaves) that had proven a formidable force unafraid to make big hits. He sat Cracknell in favor of Vladimir Tarasenko, who has struggled to make plays since he exploded early in the season. Tarasenko’s a lot of things, but he’s not a heavy hitter that could replace Cracknell in terms of enforcing the Blues’ checking. Tarasenko also had the least amount of playing time last night (5:51), so if Hitchcock put him on the roster to make goals, he showed little confidence in putting him on the ice so he could do so.

Reaves and Porter had the next fewest on-ice minutes with 7:55 and 8:38, respectively. Although that’s more playing time than each of them has seen in any one game of this series, giving those big hitters more opportunities to get out there and lay down the law against the Kings will go a long way to giving players like Tarasenko, Andy McDonald and Perron more room to maneuver on the ice.

The veterans have to step up to an extent though, as well. Roman Polak missed his coverage, which led to the third Kings goal. He got caught looking at goaltender Brian Elliott, instead of LA’s assistant captain Anze Kopitar who had a clear shot from maybe ten feet out. Perron has to stop letting himself get bullied in front of the Kings’ crease. McDonald needs to play less scared when he has good chances.

Still, all of these games have been close and there’s a lot to be optimistic about, especially as the  series comes back to the ScottTrade Center. Youngster Jaden Schwartz has played some of the best hockey of his young career in the last week, Oshie looks stellar coming off of his injury, and even though four went past him last night, Elliott still makes a great brick wall in front of the net.

And now, a parting message from Olivia Newton-John to the notes. Let’s Go Blues!