One of the most persistent rumors involving the St. Louis Blues this season has been a potential trade with the New York Rangers and Jordan Binnington.
While the chatter has quieted a bit over the last couple of weeks, one notable insider believes the talk should only pick up as the season goes along.
In a recent appearance on Daily Faceoff, insider David Pagnotta discussed the possibility of a Blues-Rangers deal. Even if nothing is imminent at this point, fans shouldn’t take their eye off the ball on this one.
“I don’t get the sense that anything is imminent right now… They (Rangers) want to rush into a decision… I started seeing some chatter about Jordan Binnington being a target.”
In Pagnotta’s estimation, the deal hinges on the Rangers’ goaltending situation. If their current tandem does not hold up, there might be a temptation to utilize Igor Shesterkin’s cap space to make a move this season.
It’s worth pointing out that when the Rangers moved Shesterkin to season-ending LTIR, they freed up the entirety of his $11.65 million cap space. That’s more than enough room right now to add a goalie like Binnington to their roster.
“I expect him to be a target because he’s on an expiring contract. I think they’re going to try to utilize this money depending on how the rest of their season goes here… If they’re still well within the race in the Metro, at least in the top three, go out there and try to get some pieces that not only improve your goaltending, but also perhaps improve some other areas of the club.”
"I'd expect [Binnington] to be a target for the [New York Rangers]."
— Daily Faceoff (@DailyFaceoff) November 18, 2026
David Pagnotta discusses Jordan Binnington as a potential option for the Rangers and how New York could use its additional cap flexibility.
Presented by @ProrasoUSA #ShaveLikeAPro pic.twitter.com/Yvx2M0so2T
The idea is an intriguing one, but there are plenty of variables up in the air.
Time may have come for Blues to move on from Binnington
It’s become pretty evident that the time has come for the Blues to move on from Binnington. Joel Hofer has staked his claim as the team’s starting netminder.
That situation won’t change unless Binnington somehow loses his mind and goes on a shocking run that leaves Hofer in the dust.
Plus, with Binnington as an impending UFA, the Blues have little incentive to keep him. Unless Binnington is so committed to the Blues that he is willing to stay on a much more team-friendly deal next season, the Blues would do well to cash in on him now.
That said, a specific deal with the New York Rangers would depend on how things go this season in New York. Pagnotta is right when he points out that this entire discussion depends on the Rangers being playoff contenders.
If they remain in the thick of the Eastern Conference playoff race, Binnington could become a very attractive target. Otherwise, the Blues might find another suitor elsewhere looking to get some help in the crease.
One last thing: Hofer will need a new contract this season. That’s why the Blues will be more interested in figuring out how much it will cost them to keep their starting goalie before re-signing Binnington. As it stands, the numbers don’t look good for a return of Jordan Binnington to St. Louis next season.
