The St. Louis Blues are puttering along with a 9-9-2 record and sit seventh in a competitive Central Division. It's been a pretty mixed bag, outside of the incredible play of Joel Hofer--and with the anecdotal American Thanksgiving cutoff looming in a little over a week, it could be getting late early.
The 2026-27 season has been full of disappointments, but these three may be the biggest.
The invisible top line
The Blues' leading scorers are, of course, Robert Thomas, Jimmy Snuggerud, and Dylan Holloway, all of whom have 14 points in 20 games. The problem is that, outside of Snuggerud, neither Holloway nor Thomas--nor anyone else on the team--is able to actually put pucks in the net. Holloway and Thomas are two of the team's highest-paid players, and Snuggerud's in line for a significant raise once his Entry-Level Contract is up this summer, and none of them are living up to expectations.
It doesn't help that the team's depth has stagnated. Dalibor Dvorsky's been underwhelming and is finding himself on the fourth line of late, Pavel Buchnevich's strong start didn't last, and the defense behind Philip Broberg is deeply concerning. Speaking of depth...
The summer's trades may not be working out after all
Mason McTavish got off to a hot start, tallying six goals and four assists in his first 10 games in St. Louis. In the 10 games since, he has just two points--and both came in the same game against the New Jersey Devils. Tonight's game against the team that traded him, the Anaheim Ducks, hopefully lights a fire under him to get his scoring touch back.
The Blues' other major acquisition, Connor McMichael, has underwhelmed to date as well. Like McTavish, McMichael started strong, with six points in his first six games with the Blues. The 14 games since, though? Three points--all assists. Not nearly good enough.
The early returns on both trades were positive, but boy, has each player fizzled. The top line isn't scoring, and the secondary scoring reinforcements added over the summer have flatlined.
An unplayable backup goaltender
Jordan Binnington's legacy with the St. Louis Blues is set: he backstopped the team to its first-ever Stanley Cup in 2019, and won a Silver Medal in Milan during the Winter Olympics last year. There's a decent chance his jersey will hang from the rafters when he hangs up his pads.
Now, though, the Blues are actively putting themselves at a disadvantage every time he starts a game. His .851 SV% is third-worst among goaltenders with five or more games this season. Thank goodness Joel Hofer has been so strong to start the year, because it's covered up many of the Blues' shortcomings--those roster issues are on full display every time Binnington takes the net, though. It's dangerous to keep running Hofer out so much, too, because he could wear down or--worse--get injured, and then the Blues would really be in trouble.
Binnington's pretty much the only goalie left on the trade board, after Connor Hellebuyck was moved to the New Jersey Devils. A change of scenery may do the veteran well, now that Hofer's taken over as the starter in St. Louis--and maybe the Blues can get back an actually playable backup netminder in whatever deal they can arrange.
